Animal Stories - Knifefish

Animal-World info on Redtail Botia
Animal Story on Redtail Botia
List Animal Stories on Redtail Botia
More info at Animal-World
david - 2011-06-12
Could I keep a Clown Knifefish in a 55 gallon aquarium? The tank will have subdued lighting and be lightly planted with cryptocorne, Java Fern and Java Moss. There will be numerous hiding places created by bogwood and rocks. I would also like to add a Red-tailed Black Shark, among other Southeast Asian fish. Would this work out?

Click For Replies (1)
  • Charlie Roche - 2011-06-13
    It doesn't sound like a real good idea. The shark fish tail would eaily fit into the Knifefish mouth and the Knifefish can grow to 11 pounds. Clownfish are the quieter of the two and usually don't cause problems but will eat anything they can fit in their mouth. But the sharks are agressive and could tease or want territory and there would be the problem.
Animal-World info on Black Ghost Knife Fish
Animal Story on Black Ghost Knife Fish
List Animal Stories on Black Ghost Knife Fish
More info at Animal-World
Kyle - 2010-02-21
I have received lots of comments regarding my post on BGKs. And although the inch per gallon rule doesn't apply to large fish, my knifefish isn't that big. He's only five inches or so. Secondly, he has a large home to move into. Once my BGK is big enough, he has a 200 gallon tank with 3 tiger oscars to move into. I'm just growing him in a smaller tank until he can live with oscars without being a snack. And if you keep on top of your water changes, you can push the rule to the limit and have healthy and happy fish. I clean my tank every saturday morning and I usually do a 20-25% water change. And lastly bottom feeders like pleco contribute 75% less waste than any other fish so they practically don't count towards the inch per gallon rule. Because of this a 10" pleco counts for about 2.5-3" of space. Because of this many people say they just don't count. Do you even know how to tell when a pleco is too long for the tank? If a pleco is at the top of the tank and his length is 2/3 the length of the glass then he is too long. Many people don't know that. Thank you Calvin for your support. Its finally nice to talk to some one who actually knows what they're talking about (unlike J and Z). To give you a brief summary of my 44 G tank, it isn't your standard rectangular tank. Its a custom made corner unit (explaining the unusual size). My BGK has a cave that looks like the Roman Colosseum. He usually spends the most of his time during the day in his little hideaway, but during feeding time, he rushes out to gobble down a small chunk of frozen bloodworm. He spends his nights swimming in all sorts of weird patterns. My pH is about 7.4. in my set up. I would also like to hear about your unique sounding setup. I look forward to hearing back from you.

Click For Replies (5)
  • Becka - 2010-10-09
    Hi Kyle, I've just been reading your posts and you seem to know what you're doing. My partner recently set up our aquarium but we are TOTAL novices.
    We've got 5 neons (ghost fish ate one), 2 glow tetras, 2 angelfish, 2 balloon mollies, a longfin fighter fish (who's now recooping in a breeder tank after our BGKF blew one of his eyes out) and our blessed little BGKF who's around 5 inches too.

    We're in New Zealand (South Island) so the water here is about as close to neutral as it gets and super clean.We only have a 50 gallon tank though. We knew when we bought the fish we'd eventually have to upgrade the tank, but after reading all these posts I'm worried our tank is already overcrowded?

    We already have all the fish, and upgrading the tank right now is difficult because our town just had a massive earthquake.... erm any ideas?
  • Lisa - 2010-12-09
    Kyle - You are SO terribly wrong about the plecos. Plecos are one of the heaviest waste producers in a tank. They poo ALL the time.
    So no, a pleco is NOT a low waste producer, they're actually pretty bad.

    And I would still be hesitant to add your BGK to a tank with 3 large? oscars, even if the BGK is a decent size. Because it's narrow, it could still end up as lunch for the oscars.
  • Anita - 2011-02-21
    I agree with Lisa. Plecos are huge waste producers. I have several, trust me. My big guy in my 125 gal is the messiest fish I've ever had, and that's saying something considering some of the fish I've kept. I think when you're referring to your inch per gallon rule with bottom feeders you're thinking of things like loachs and catfish. Cory cats aren't bad with waste and my clown loaches and botia's aren't bad with waste either. And even then, I still don't agree. Any person I've ever talked to with serious experience has told me that bottom feeders count just the same.
  • Anthony powell - 2011-05-01
    I totally agree with the comments regarding the plecos. I originally had 2 plecs but the waste produced by them was that bad I reduced it to one thinking that would be better. Nope didn't make a difference at all. I'm sure the other plec produced more waste just to spite me cuz I got rid of his mate. So I got rid of that one too. In summary. Plec = lots of waste.
  • david - 2011-06-12
    Plecostomus (I believe we are talking about Glyptopterichthys gibbiceps) is a very large waste producer. A Plecostomus by itself will require a thirty gallon tank. Therefore, if you have a 55 gallon, the Plecostomus alone will take up 30 gallons of that tank. On a waste producing chart, G. Gibbiceps are right alongside Oscars. Trust me.
Animal-World info on African Knife Fish
Animal Story on African Knife Fish
List Animal Stories on African Knife Fish
More info at Animal-World
Will N. - 2009-06-01
Yes, 30 gallons is way too small. Same for your tinfoil barbs, which if in a larger aquarium will get HUGE!. In your tank they will become stunted and die. Get a bigger tank and learn how to keep fish.

Click For Replies (3)
  • Marsha C. Mais - 2011-04-18
    That is out right nasty sir. You're idea of keeping fish isn't the same as others. Being rude isn't the answer.
  • Tyler Pelleran - 2011-05-15
    @marsha he is correct actually and your idea of fish keeping is wrong they will get stunted and die
  • Dark Horse - 2011-06-05
    Sure he's right.
Animal-World info on Black Ghost Knife Fish
Animal Story on Black Ghost Knife Fish
List Animal Stories on Black Ghost Knife Fish
More info at Animal-World
keesha edward - 2011-04-09
Hi there. My husband and myself purchased our two ghost knives about 3 years ago or so. They were tiny when we first bought them, about 2 inches long. They are now about 10 inches. T o our surprise last night we saw a ghost kinfe of about 3 inches swimming around. This came as a complete shock as we were not expecting them to have babies at all. In all the years we have had our tank none of our tropical fish have bred. Im not sure how big they are when they are born so perhaps this fella has been around for a while and we just have not noticed? We have a tank of about 580L. We very proud and quiet amazed that this has happened as I believe this is very unusual??

keesha edward
south africa

Animal-World info on Clown Knifefish
Animal Story on Clown Knifefish
List Animal Stories on Clown Knifefish
More info at Animal-World
Charles - 2011-03-25
Howard is my 26 inch clown. I have had him for almost 2 years now. He loves goldfish and will eat pellets. He lives with his friends Peter and Conan the Plecos in a 120 gal. tank. I am looking for a 200 for them.

Animal-World info on Black Ghost Knife Fish
Animal Story on Black Ghost Knife Fish
List Animal Stories on Black Ghost Knife Fish
More info at Animal-World
Vikki Fraser - 2011-03-15
Hello I hope someone can help I have a black ghost knife fish and am concerned that he is scared in my tank he is in with a red tailed shark and the shark will not leave him the red tail playing or being aggressive I am not sure also are you better feeding late at night so that the ghost knife fish is getting enough food?

Animal-World info on Bronze Featherback
Animal Story on Bronze Featherback
List Animal Stories on Bronze Featherback
More info at Animal-World
hasham - 2011-03-10
These fish are territorial with other of same kind and quite aggressive to other fish as well. So not peaceful at all. It would like to dig in substrate much like Cichlids. Mine would take sinking pellets and feeder fish.

Animal-World info on Black Ghost Knife Fish
Animal Story on Black Ghost Knife Fish
List Animal Stories on Black Ghost Knife Fish
More info at Animal-World
cspruce427 - 2011-03-06
Most pics show jet black ghost knifefish, your pic shows a grayer fish like I just bought. Can you tell me why?

Anonymous - 2011-02-25
Hi, last night when feeding my black ghost knife fish I noticed he has a scratch on the top of his back! I'm kind of worried about him and was wondering if there is anything I can do for him? It's almost half an inch long and I have no idea how he could of gotten it. Is there anything I can do for him? Or will it just heal on its own?

Amy - 2010-08-04
I was wondering what is the smallest size of tank you can put a 4in BGK in? We had one and the guy @ the pet store said it would do fine in a 10g tank with 2 tiger barbs (I think that's what they're called) an angel fish a goldfish and a pleco and a molly. They also told us to feed it freeze-dried bloodworms. It wouldn't eat them and it died and I was wondering what we did wrong and how to correct it so if we get another one the same thing doesn't happen to it. Because obviously we did something wrong cause it died. Please any advice would be helpful. And if it was stupidity feel free to tell me that as well.

Click For Replies (4)
  • janine - 2010-08-18
    Amy there may have been something wrong from the get go. Your bkgf may have had a problem b4 he got there. I have a bgkf and he has been doing wonderful and we have some of the WORST water in the country here to work with. That is WAY too many fish to put in a ten gal tank with a ghost fish unless you only mean to do it for a short while. We kept ours in a ten gal till he outgrew that and he lives with an upside down catfish. Now in a 20 gal tank and is too big for it! So, you can't give him too many neighbors. They are scaleless which is one thing you need to remember, can't medicate the water for them as you would for others and watch their skin for any breaks in color or smoothness to let ya know if you need to pay attention to water quality or tankmate fights and such. Injuries, parasites or fungus. We really delight in our black ghost knife fish, he loves to frolick in his tank which he seems to be a watchdog over. :) Our knife fish is over ten inches long now, chases that catfish around when the catfish pokes him as he invades his cave. It's just all so funny. He barks at the catfishes house sooooooooooooo funny. But we are blessed by him. Try again sweetheart, k? But DO be prepared to get a bigger house for him and DO give him a log or cave and some deco to hide in, k? I would choose peaceable tankmates for your black ghost. No barbs! Meaning none of those barbs on the fish because a skin break can mean sick or loss of the black. We pray for ours. He a happy happy fish and I am soooo glad we bought him.! All the best and feel free to ask anything.
  • Ashlee - 2010-08-22
    BGK's need like 100 gallons. Always do plenty of research before you buy. That person at the petstore has no idea what they're talking about.
  • Anita - 2011-01-05
    Amy, don't take this the wrong way but what are you doing with an angel, 2 barbs, a goldfish, a pleco and molly in a 10 gallon? That is a majorly over crowded tank! Also, goldfish should not be a part of that group at all. Pick tropical fish or goldfish. Also, your angel and your pleco should both be in bigger tanks. That's cramping them.
    One, BGK's need a lot of room. I didn't even think about getting my first one until I had a 60 gal to put him in and I put him there knowing that there was a good chance I was going to have to move him into a larger tank in the future. Second, most fish don't seem to like freeze dried food all that well. They will eat it, but they prefer frozen or live. You have to make sure your BGK is getting enough good food and freeze dried wasn't going to do the trick. Mine personally loves his frozen blood worms. He also gets omega one flakes, frozen brine shrimp, frozen mysis shrimp, and sometimes live worms and shrimp.
    My advice: don't get another BGK until you have a much bigger tank and are willing to spend the extra money to buy frozen or live often.
  • Anonymous - 2011-02-13
    10 gallon way too SMALL! feed live food!

About Animal-World

Animal-World offers animal pictures, videos, and animal information on all different types of pets and animals. Included are animals that are commonly kept as pets, exotic pets and wild animals. Check us out for information, education, and fun. We strive to aid in responsible pet ownership and an understanding of the importance of preserving and honoring our world and its inhabitants. Animal-World members and contributors are from all over the world. You too are invited to be an active participant in this community. Post your own personal pet stories, contribute pictures of your pets, and join the forums for pet and animal discussions.

Visit Animal-World